Wow. Wow. Wow.
I am amazed that the one thing in Itachi's story to Sasuke - the thing that I read and realized 'Itachi is lying', is apparently something that happened. I never thought Naruto was raped by dogs. From the moment it was said, I thought it was too difficult to accomplish and that Obito would never be able to manage it. And yet, it seems it had. Maybe?? Because Naruto passes out, so maybe he just thinks it happened and Obito was counting on that. Even so, as far as I am concerned, there is no redemption for Obito. There is no way I can see Naruto forgiving him in the future. Wow. To treat your (believed) soulmate like that? The fact that Obito hits him. Damn. The whole scene where Obito speaks Itachi's poisoned words are so incredibly... dark and painful. There were a few times I had to pause reading before resuming. It's a tough scene. Well written, incredible, and an amazing feat. As a work of fiction, it is incredible, but wow it is dark and painful as a reader attached to these characters.
One thing that is not clear is if the dog thing was Itachi's idea. He says it to Sasuke - and he is not in the room - so I presume it was. Somehow, I don't see Obito doing that on his own, but damn. Itachi must have done something amazing with the blackmail on the White Lady.
This chapter is dark and filled with a pain that permeates the chapter. Starting with the end, one of the most profound parts of this chapter is Obito's speech to Naruto. We know that Itachi told Obito what to say, gave him a script. And even if we didn't know that, Obito sounds so much like Itachi here. HE uses the same words, speaks to Naruto in the same way. It's strange and also poetic because it doesn't even seem like Itachi tried to make it sound like something Obito would say. Reading this, if you removed the tags, I would say 'that's Itachi talking,' because it sounds so much like his narrative voice in the story.
Oh boy, this one is sad. From the jump, we already know what Madara is going to do and reading the chapter does not make that fact any easier. It also makes total sense that Madara would do what he's going to do. Naruto is just a ward and Obito is his son. That said, I do like the detail of "Obito si lasciò prendere e portare via da me quieto." the fact that Obito goes and allows it to happen because he knows he messed up. The fact he doesn't make the scene worse is that much better. The resigned nature of Obito here is amazing character development. Even if he wants Madara to use his position so that he to get away with it and keeps Naruto.
Also, I have no idea why, but when Madara is holding his nose and says "Che il Nostro Sacro Sovrano mia dia la forza per sopportare un figlio così stupido» pregò acido" I genuinely laughed out loud. The scene is so serious and somehow, that one line cuts so much of the tension. I know that I probably shouldn't like Madara as a character given what we know about him, but I do like him. He's one of the better characters and my god, he's funny.
The whole scene with Madara is just fantastic. I love it whenever Madara shows up in the story because he's such a presence and he makes such an impact. He is absolutely fantastic. That said, I do like that he is not constantly in the story, as it would remove a good portion of the mystery surrounding him and what Sakura intends to do. But wow, he has so little 'screen time', and he establishes such a presence. Bravo, L. Madara has so little time in the story and he still manages to establish such a presence. Wow.
The way Naruto finds out that Itachi isn't his brother is not as Itachi depicted it and I like that. Obito's emotional reactivity causes so much of the conflict in the story that I presume this will continue when we jump forward in time to the real conflict. I can easily see Obito causing more issues. Maybe he learned some impulse control in 19 years, but given what we see of him in the main story, I doubt very much that's the same. I also like that Madara tells Obito that he has to tell him now that he ruined it. And, of course, in comes Zetsu to explain and clean up the mess Obito made. Again, love the progression of this, despite how sad it is.
Hmm, given what we know about Kushina and Minato, I find myself more and more curious about the truth of their lives. For starters, we see that there is a lot of bias in the telling of the story, and the short story presented here is believable and I do believe that it happened more or less the way it is described here. However, there has to be more to the story, and I find myself curious as to if there is more truth that Zetsu did not tell Naruto, or, something Naruto is not telling Sasuke. This scene plays out differently than the others. Naruto's desire not to say anything about is parents makes total sense. I understand why he holds back and gives short, fragmented details. However, we do not 'hear' what Zetsu shared with Naruto and the additional details that may be helpful. Also, we know that Zetsu does not always tell the truth. It is unclear if Zetsu would be able to lie to Naruto or not, however, I do like the idea that Naruto cannot tell when Zetsu lies, in a similar way to how Naruto does not seem to have a sexual effect on Zetsu (outside of the one instance with his pheromones that we see).
"I suoi genitori erano stati condannati alla ghigliottina dal Governo, da Madara." Oh, wow. I don't think this has been revealed in the story! Talk about learning something about Zetsu. That makes sense.
One thing that is very powerful in this chapter is something Iruka said, how Naruto and Sasuke were very much alike. The line "Mi avevano fatto nascere solo per quello." is true for Naruto, but in some sense, it is also true to Sasuke. Sasuke was born specifically for Naruto. Or, that is what we are led to believe. After all, it is entirely possible that Itachi had other intentions and Sasuke ended up with Naruto as a matter of convenience. Still, the fact that Sasuke was meant for Naruto likely means that Itachi had to use the same tactic to keep Sasuke alive, but that Sasuke is basically also just a person for Naruto to have sex with. This line stands out to me in the tragedy of Naruto's life, and the fact that Sasuke was essentially subjected to the same fate.
Curiously, we also see how Naruto's lies to Itachi seem to influence Itachi's lies to Sasuke. I find it remarkable that some of the lies that Itachi told to Sasuke are actually caused because Naruto lied to Itachi. This is not necessarily important, but I find it fascinating that almost all of the lies and inconsistencies in Itachi's stories actually originate in Naruto. That makes me wonder if Itachi is actually honest and forthright with Sasuke. He said he always wanted a brother, didn't he? And that is chilling in knowing what Itachi is capable of. Wow. Incredible attention to detail.
The first scene with Itachi is one of the many reasons I like him in the story. He does genuinely seem to want what is good for Naruto. Again, he seems to be doing his best and even gives Naruto time in his room, alone, to accept what's happening. We know that the goodness in Itachi won't last, and perhaps it is a manipulation tactic, but I like that Itachi is not always doing terrible things. There are moments were Itachi is good and genuine in the story, even if his moral framework is damaged. And I think that's part of the purpose of him in the narrative. Itachi does terrible things. He thinks that he loves Naruto even though he hurts him and pimps him out. And yet, in the system that they are in, this disturbing, corrupted power struggle... it almost feels like Itachi is just as powerless as Naruto at times. That does not excuse Itachi of course, but he is an interesting character. I like that he is not just evil.
Izumi reappears in this chapter and is living with Itachi, they even have a house together. I find myself wondering again why they are not yet married - is it Itachi's choice? Is it Izumi's because it's clear that Itachi doesn't love her? Is it Shisui because she is so in love with Itachi that he will not allow Itachi to truly marry his sister? Is it Izuna because he wants to be sure Itachi will be worth something before marrying them? Or, if Alpha females have limited fertility windows, is izuna delaying as much as he can to prevent Itachi from having his own heir to surpass him and potentially trying to cause another succession crisis? Perhaps that's more detail than needed, given what we have seen. Itachi's obsession with Naruto could very well be the answer, but if it is a political marriage, then a delay seems strange. Unless Itachi is trying to end up in a situation like Naruto to Hinata, where he lands a much better specially advantageous marriage. This is a minor detail, but I find it strange that they have been engaged for what? The better part of a decade? And almost two more decades will pass and they are still not married in the main story. A thirty year engagement. A part of me wonders if this is normal in universe of it if it really strange. Someone else - I believe Kakashi? - points out how long they have been engaged, so I assume it's not normal.
Naruto hitting Shisui is nice. It's a good form of catharsis. However, we also see Naruto taking on one of Obito's worse traits, violence. This gets into dicey territory, because we could say Naruto defending himself and being able to fight is a good thing. However, this is just reacting. We see Naruto later has many of Obito's not so great mannerisms. At first, when I read it, it totally make sense to me that Naruto was finally reacting, that he was protecting himself, that he was having emotional outbursts and destroying rooms. Now though? Really focusing on what's happening to him, he's swinging from one extreme to another and I'm not sure the violent outbursts are that good, especially with what we see him do later in the story, especially to Sasuke. And upon reading, "Perché tutto è sbagliato, va distrutto." I feel empathy for Naruto. He has nothing else. He has no tools to express himself, no ability to healthily regulate his emotions. I totally understand why his only way of coping is to destroy in this case, but that doesn't mean it's a good thing.
The scene where "Tutto tornò come prima." is also insanely interesting. Itachi tends to be expressionless and emotionless in most situations. I find it curious that in situations where Naruto shows emotion, Itachi associates that with a crisis and that's when he rapes him. Perhaps I am giving Itachi too much benefit of the doubt, but that genuinely feels like a learned behavior to me. Given the fact that there's a family orgie on Naruto's birthday and the fact that Izumi, Shisui, and Izuna raped Sasuke together - someone who is related to all of them. Say nothing of the fact that all of them are related, really does seem to indicate that incest is not a big deal in Uchiha at all. Not publicly, obviously, but in private? It seems totally fine in Uchiha. That makes me wonder if Itachi is repeating the same things that happened to him on Naruto. This in no way excuses Itachi, but it is a thought I have had so many times. Another possibility is that Kushina was supposed to have raised Itachi instead of Mitoko. So, it is not outrageous that Minato or Kushina also did something to Itachi. After all, Itachi did all he could save Kushina's son. Part of me feels there has to be a reason behind such affection, especially since Itachi seems to have been sexually attracted to Naruto from the start. The only real evidence I can point to in this chapter is that Itachi thinks Obito taking care of Naruto requires sex. Granted, that could be something Itachi assumed given how he diagnosed Naruto with nymphomania to suit his own needs and desires, but it could also indicate something else. The fact that Itachi conflates love with sex seems like something he learned. It just feels like Itachi needs to be needed, that only by others relying on him does he feel loved. This fact makes Sasuke so much more susceptible to Itachi's manipulation.
One part of Naruto racconta that stands out to me if when Naruto breaks from his narrative and starts talking directly to Sasuke. This one simple narrative device is so powerful and reminds the reader that this is a story he is telling. You told us that this is the truth and that Naruto's POV is not reliable, and these moments when he speaks directly to Sasuke show that. The breaking down, the apologies, the uncertainty in this chapter is incredible. I love the moments when he speaks to Sasuke. It's been forever and I am excited for him to return. But wow, this is a powerful narrative device.
Oh man. Naruto betraying Obito and revealing everything to Itachi. Again, I totally understand why Naruto did what he did, using the only thing he had, sex and information, to get back to Obito. But wow. It hurts. Part of me is glad we don't see the detail of the betrayal. It is likely something Naruto wouldn't have been able to detail, so I do appreciate that we don't have all the details here. I also love that he apologizes to Sasuke, almost like he wants to apologize to Obito. It's sad and almost painful to know of the betrayal and that as much as Naruto regrets it, there is nothing he can do. In some ways, I can say this is an example of Madara making a decision without fully understanding what Naruto was and what he knew.
-- until next time
S |